One Man’s Criminal Past Was a Campaign Weapon. Another’s Is a Qualification. Who Benefits From Blackburn’s Appointments?
After millions were spent attacking Hatley's old conviction, Blackburn appoints former inmate Josh Smith to lead Tennessee prisons. His CoreCivic ties, the company's campaign donations, and its former CEO's Senate ambitions raise questions.
After millions were spent attacking David Hatley’s decades-old conviction, Blackburn’s appointment of Josh Smith raises questions about political double standards, CoreCivic’s campaign contributions, and whether powerful donors will benefit from the incoming administration.
There is something remarkable about the contrast between the rhetoric Tennessee voters heard throughout the gubernatorial election and Governor-elect Marsha Blackburn’s November 16 announcement. For months, independent candidate David Hatley’s decades-old criminal history was weaponized to question his character and fitness for public office. Now Blackburn has selected Josh Smith, a former federal inmate convicted of drug-related crimes who served approximately five years in prison, to lead the Tennessee Department of Correction. Suddenly, the conversation is about redemption, second chances, and the value of learning from past mistakes.
I believe in redemption and second chances, which is precisely why this appointment deserves scrutiny. Beyond the obvious inconsistency lies something considerably more troubling: CoreCivic, its financial support for Blackburn, its documented connections to Smith, and the possibility that its former CEO could receive an appointment to the United States Senate. When the corporation involved holds approximately $250 million in state prison contracts, these relationships cannot simply be dismissed as political coincidence.
Nearly $10 Million to Make Hatley’s Past the Issue
David Hatley never concealed his youthful financial misconduct. His 1998 federal fraud conviction involved financial wrongdoing, and he has publicly stated that he served just 23 days in jail. He subsequently built substantial businesses employing hundreds of Tennesseans, yet his past became the centerpiece of a campaign portraying him as untrustworthy. According to reports, two outside political committees spent nearly $10 million attacking Hatley, much of it emphasizing his decades-old financial problems. Blackburn’s campaign also created a website dedicated to discrediting him.
The double standard is difficult to ignore. Hatley’s decades-old criminal history was weaponized in a multimillion-dollar campaign to portray him as unfit for public office, while Smith’s more extensive criminal history is now being presented as part of a compelling redemption story and even an asset to his appointment. Both men rebuilt their lives and achieved considerable success after their convictions, yet only one was afforded the benefit of that transformation in the political messaging surrounding him. Apparently, redemption is a virtue worth celebrating when the political establishment is making the appointment, but a liability to be exploited when someone is challenging its power.
Josh Smith’s Past—and His More Recent Controversies
Smith’s rehabilitation is substantial. After serving approximately five years for federal drug offenses, he became a businessman, established the Fourth Purpose Foundation, and received a presidential pardon from Donald Trump in 2021. He was subsequently appointed deputy director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons in 2025. His firsthand experience with incarceration may offer useful perspectives on rehabilitation, but his more recent government service also deserves examination, particularly given the responsibility he will assume over Tennessee’s correctional system.
According to an August 25 CBS News investigation, Smith abruptly departed the Bureau of Prisons amid complaints from correctional employees, allegations of retaliation, and questions concerning federal consulting contracts. Smith disputed criticism of his management and denied involvement in the contracting decisions. The allegations have not been established as misconduct, nor has his departure been shown to constitute a firing. Nevertheless, those concerns are directly relevant to evaluating his qualifications, particularly when his incoming responsibilities include prison personnel, administrative oversight, and substantial taxpayer-funded contracts.
Follow the Money: Blackburn, CoreCivic, and Smith
CoreCivic operates four state prisons in Tennessee and maintains a substantial financial relationship with state government. In March, the Tennessee Lookout reported that CoreCivic and its then-former CEO, Damon Hininger, had contributed a combined $100,000 to Team Tennessee, a political action committee supporting Blackburn. In June, reports that Hininger and his wife had each contributed $21,200 directly to Blackburn’s gubernatorial campaign, with Hininger providing another $50,000 to a campaign-linked PAC. These are documented financial relationships involving a company whose state contracts depend upon the very department Smith has been selected to oversee.
Smith also has documented connections to CoreCivic-sponsored activities. On February 22, 2022, he participated in a Men of Valor criminal justice policy event at Tennessee’s Cordell Hull Building, specifically designed for lawmakers and legislative staff. The event flyer preserved in Tennessee Ethics Commission records identifies Smith as a speaker representing the Fourth Purpose Foundation and CoreCivic as a sponsor. Two years later, CoreCivic published an extensive feature celebrating Smith’s personal transformation and professional achievements. These connections demonstrate an established public association, although they do not establish that CoreCivic employed Smith, compensated him, or influenced his appointment.
The distinction matters, but so does the obvious potential for conflicts of interest. Did CoreCivic executives recommend Smith for the commissioner position? Has the company or its executives contributed financially to his foundation? Were there discussions with Blackburn’s transition team concerning his selection, and what safeguards will exist to ensure independent oversight of CoreCivic’s contracts? These are questions that financial disclosures, nonprofit records, and communications could help answer. The public should not have to rely exclusively on assurances from individuals whose political and financial interests intersect.
And Then There Is Blackburn’s Senate Seat
Former CoreCivic CEO Damon Hininger has openly expressed interest in replacing Blackburn in the United States Senate. He stepped down as the company’s chief executive at the end of 2025 and has maintained longstanding relationships with Blackburn and Governor Bill Lee. Following Blackburn’s election victory, Hininger attended her November 4 press conference with Lee, where she declined to say whether she intended to appoint him. According to the Tennessee Lookout, Hininger acknowledged his interest in the position, although no appointment has been announced.
Consider these developments together. CoreCivic and its former CEO provide substantial financial support to Blackburn, whose political allies spend millions attacking an independent challenger’s criminal history. Following the election, Blackburn selects a former federal inmate with documented CoreCivic associations to oversee Tennessee’s prisons, while CoreCivic’s former CEO is publicly interested in receiving the Senate appointment. None of this proves that political favors were promised or exchanged, but it establishes a convergence of financial relationships, political influence, and potential appointments that demands transparency.
Redemption for Some, Political Favors for Others?
The central issue is not whether Josh Smith deserves redemption. It is whether the same standards of character, accountability, and qualifications apply when the political establishment is rewarding an ally rather than attacking a challenger. Tennessee voters watched millions spent portraying Hatley’s past as disqualifying, only to see Blackburn celebrate another man’s criminal history as part of his qualifications for public service. Meanwhile, documented campaign contributions and corporate relationships raise legitimate questions about whose interests will be represented in the incoming administration.
The money is documented. The relationships are documented. The appointments and political ambitions are public. What remains unanswered is whether these decisions are independent or reflect commitments made behind closed doors. Tennessee voters deserve those answers, particularly after a campaign in which character and trustworthiness were treated as paramount considerations. The election may be over, but accountability does not end when the votes are counted. In fact, given what is already emerging, it may be more important now than ever.
TruthWire exists to provide independent investigative journalism that holds Tennessee’s political establishment accountable.
Independent journalism depends on the support of readers who believe in that mission.
Your contributions help us continue investigating the issues, asking difficult questions, and reporting the stories that matter to Tennesseans. If you value our work, please consider becoming a monthly supporter. Every contribution makes a difference.